Hmmm I have to agree with the negative comments re Olympia, in 30 odd years of coming to San Stef, the only bad meal I have ever had was there in 2008. My husband is a chef so knows a bit about food and isnt someone who is critical of other chefs but likes to experience different cultures and cuisines, but the meal we had at Olympia was really really bad
However he loves Spiros at Nafsika and they are always gassing about bloody food and recipes whenever we are there!
I do know what people mean about cliqueyness in SS - some regulars do tend to like the preferential treatment offered and newbies sometimes can feel a bit sidelined, but its still a really lovely friendly place and hopefully no one would be put off going back!